Summary of QRI 5:
The QRI 5 provides two major components in students, can a
student identify words and comprehend a text and if a student is unsuccessful
in word identification and comprehension. The assessment is individual to each
student and based on informal reading. These assessments also help teachers determine
their students reading level for guided reading, independent reading and other
reading activities that are done in the classroom.
Summary of DIBELS:
DIBELS are procedures and measures that access student’s
achievements in grades k-6th literacy skills. All of the assessments
with in the DIBELS are short and only 1 minute long, each assessment measures
early literacy and reading skills. The purpose of designing the DIBELS is to
help identify students who are struggling early on as a preventative measure.
The seven measures that are in the DIBELS are as followed, phonemic awareness,
alphabetic principle, accuracy and fluency with connected text, reading
comprehension and vocabulary.
Similarities:
Both the QRI 5 and DIBELS are assessments that measure students
reading level and listening level/ability. As well both assessments allow you
to record and track the students results. They also both give teachers the
ability to assess again and track students progress. Both assessments are also
done in a short time period.
Differences:
Some differences of both assessments include that the QRI 5 is
for students in grades 1st-12th, and DIBELS are for
students in grades k-6th. The scoring is also significantly different
as for the QRI 5 each student score is individually based on how they do.
DIBELS scores students against a group of students. Each part of both
assessments are also scored differently.